All of our nut butters are fresh ground at our store with no additives.

We have 10 varieties of nut butters 

in an assortment of sizes.

Honey Roasted - Organic - Natural

Butterscotch - Chocolate - Cappuccino

Almond - Cashew - Hazelnut

Check out our wide variety of delicious Jams, Jellies and Marmalades!

Flavors include:  Apricot - Apricot Jalapeno - 

Black Currant - Blackberry - Boysenberry
Cranberry Butter - Cranberry Jalapeno - Habanero Lingonberry - Mint - Mango Plum Ginger - Orange Pineapple Jalapeno - Pumpkin Butter - Strawberry

Raspberry Jalapeno - Raspberry Rhubarb
Strawberry Rhubarb - ​Sweet Onion Jalapeno
Sweet Wine - Tangerine - 
Wild Blueberry

Treat Yourself to a sack or jar

of delicious peanuts from

Bertie County, NC! 

Available in Salty, Hot & Spicy,

Honey Roasted, Blister Fried, 

Sea Salt & Black Pepper and more!

Open Daily 9:30am-6pm
(7pm on  Friday & Saturday)

516 Carpenters Lane

Cape May 

(609) 898-4444

Delicious and Different!

We carry Three Flavors of Montebello Kitchens Peanut Soup.

Thai Curry

African Sweet Potato

Traditional Virginian

Wake Up to Wholesome Goodness!

This gourmet pancake & waffle mix by Robert Rothschild Farm comes in 2 varieties.

Wild Blueberry & Meyer Lemon 

Red Raspberry

The Great San Saba River Pecan Company

This line is well-known for its strong

fruit flavor. Made with large chunks
​of fruit and pecans.

Try our delicious Peanut Butter
Cup Cocoa Mix or one of our

Flavored Coffees by
​Crescent Moon

Treat yourself to one of our delicious Peanut Butter candies! 

From Colossal Peanut Butter Cups
to Crunchy Peanut Butter Brittle,
​you are sure to find something to
​satisfy your sweet tooth.

Home                  About Us                Contact Us

Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

Open Daily 9:30am-6pm (7pm on Friday & Saturday)   516 Carpenters Lane, Cape May     (609) 898-4444

Check out our line of clothing and accessories! 

We have T-shirts, Hats, Aprons and even Earrings!


 Try one of our many peanut butter related sandwiches... Or build a custom PB sandwich of your dreams!

Eat in our courtyard or take it with you.

Call ahead and we can even have it ready for you!

Stop back often to see what delectable treats are in our bakery case. 

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcakes, Scrumptious Truffles, Giant Peanut Butter Cup Cookies & Much More.