CAPE MAY PEANUT BUTTER COMPANY is a gourmet store stacked with all kinds of sweet and savory treats inspired by the American classic!


9 Nut Butters flavors to choose from... including Honey Roast, Butter Scotch, Capu Cino, Choc Choc, Natural, Almond, Sunflower, Cashew, and Organic.


Over 40 flavors of jam including carrot cake, habanero, oatmeal stout, India pale ale and of course, grape and strawberry.


Sandwiches - There’s Fireside Delight (chocolate peanut butter and Fluff), Monkey’s Uncle (peanut butter and bananas), the Hot Stuff (peanut butter and pepper jam) and much more.


Coffee, Tea & Cocoa - NJ’s Crescent Moon coffees and teas plus their own Peanut Butter Hot Cocoa Mix.


PB Dog Treats - We have healthy dog treats made from our peanut butter. And we proudly donate to Animal Outreach of Cape May County.


Pet-Friendly Courtyard - Relax and enjoy your PB treat... friendly pets are welcome.